I’ve been doing a lot of soul searching the past few weeks. As I wrote here, I’m really in love with the Google Reader service, but I am also in love with the good old-fashioned newspaper. Is it possible for one man to love two news-delivery methods?
I’d like to settle this debate once-and-for-all, so I brought together the Google Reader and The Old-Fashioned Newspaper to see if we might conclude which news-delivery service is superior.
Hello, and thank you for having me.
Hi. Thanks for inviting me Mike.

Alright guys, why don’t you start by telling me in one sentence why you are a superior news-delivery service over your opponent. Old-Fashioned Newspaper, you start.

The newspaper, the only news-delivery system that is as old as this great country of ours, is the only news-delivery system that can be picked up at the corner market or delivered to your doorstep or read on the toilet.

What does history have to do with it? We’re talking about the here and now. And my free service is even better than having to run down to a market or step outside to retrieve a paper from the doorstep (which you paid to have delivered, by the way). And who is to say that Mike doesn’t occasionally read his RSS feeds on the toilet?
Guilty.

I thought we were supposed to give our answers in one sentence. The Google Reader’s last answer was 4 sentences! That’s another flaw with this new technology. They can’t understand the value of space limits.
There was a fire on Main Street, and I’ve only got 500 words to tell you all of the really important details. I’m not going to bog you down and bore you with superfluous information.

That’s why I’m better than you, Mr. Old-Fashioned Newspaper. I can deliver all of the details (even what you call the superfluous information) and let Mike decide how deeply he wants to read into a story. I’ve got unlimited space.
Next question: Why is your service an important part of our culture?

I can deliver the news just like a newspaper. But what I can do better than a newspaper is give you up-to-date information.
As soon as Britney runs into a church, I’m letting you know.
When the results from New Hampshire came in, I was the first to tell you about it.
Unlike your newspaper, that will tell you about it tomorrow morning, I can keep you in the know.

If newspapers die, America will die. Who will defend your freedoms? Will the police decide who is guilty or innocent? Who will act, like the Philadelphia Inquirer did in 1977?
Or what if federal scientists tell doctors what drugs and dosages are best for the people, and are secretly taking salaries and stock options from drug companies? Will we ever find out if you have no investigative reports like the one in The Los Angeles Times in 2003?
Or when a U.S. President decides to nullify the law and spy on American citizens without warrants—who, if not the New York Times—will let the people know?

This question is for The Old-Fashioned Newspaper: The Google Reader claims to be able to do everything you can…and then some. Are there any functions you provide that the Google Reader cannot?

I’m glad you asked that. The answer is definitely “YES.”
One thing that I do, that the Reader doesn’t, is that I can deliver all of the news to all of the people. Sure, this only-deliver-the-news-you-want stuff is cute and convenient for now, but this is just a fad. And really, at what cost does it come?
I know, Mike, that you like to read political and pop-culture news. If you opened up a newspaper you could get all of that information, plus you would be able to scan some of the headlines about stories you might not be too interested in. I help you stay informed in areas that you aren’t exactly passionate about. For example, what four teams are in the running for this year’s Super Bowl?
?

You see, if you had at least scanned my headlines today, you’d be privy to this kind of stuff. I makes you a better, more-rounded person.

Okay, this question is for The Google Reader. Your service requires an internet connection and also a small-amount of technical know-how. How does this not hurt your chances at becoming the number one news-delivery service?

Let me start by saying that setting up a Google Reader account is incredibly easy and doesn’t require too much “technical know-how.” We’ve made everything really easy and accessible to everyone.
And yes, my service requires an internet connection. But think about something: The internet was born in January 1985. Super Mario Brothers was released in 1990. The first SMS message was sent in 1992. Amazon and eBay launced in 1995. Hotmail in 1996.
People under 30, like you Mike, have been socially conditioned in a universe that requires an internet connection. People your age play computer games with mind-blowing complexity. You guys are natural users of computer and communications technology. You are digital natives—accustomed to creating content of your own (like this blog) and publishing it. Broadcast yourself, right YouTube?
Here are the top Technorati tags from yesterday:
- Scrabulous
- Ron Paul
- Oracle Bea
- YouTube
- OpenId
- ModBook
- MySpace
- Noelia
- Cars
- Mark Driscoll
These are topics young people care about and write about. How many stories about Scrabulous are you reading in newspapers today? Old-Fashioned Newspaper, how many of these topics were covered in today’s edition?
I’ve heard of Ron Paul.

Newspapers are dying (along with their readers). Journalism is important, but thanks to the internet its face is changing. You can find the important news and the latest celebrity gossip all on the internet. Come to me to read stuff from professional journalists and from citizens’ media in the blogosphere.

Okay, thank you both. If you could just give me a second to tally your scores.

Google Reader takes it.
It’s really true that as long as you have an internet connection, the reader can do everything your newspaper can do…and then more.
And the oh-so-humble reader didn’t even mention up above that the reader allows you to share content with your friends, add fun widgets to your own website like the one on the left of this page, use the powerful google search features, and it’s loaded with a bunch of keyboard shortcuts.
My money goes to Google.